
Learn the Trapeziectomy and Abductor pollicis longus suspensionplasty surgical technique with step by step instructions on OrthOracle. Our e-learning platform contains high resolution images and a certified CME of the Trapeziectomy and Abductor pollicis longus suspensionplasty surgical procedure.
Thumb-base arthritis, effecting one or both of the trapeziometacarpal (TMC and scapho-trapezio-trapezoid (STT) joints are very common degenerative conditions, and will trouble in the order of 1:3 people at some point. They can also arise as part of a more systemic inflammatory arthritis, or secondary to trauma to the thumb metacarpal base (such as a Bennett’s or a Rolando fracture) or damage to the intrinsic ligaments of the thumb base (the palmar oblique or beak ligament). Most patients will not need surgical treatment, but excision of the trapezium (trapeziectomy) is the gold-standard surgical treatment.
Following simple trapeziectomy, the thumb will usually shorten by a few millimetres and the absolute power of pinch grip will be reduced; for this reason, some surgeons try to combine trapeziectomy with steps to maintain thumb base stability and ray length; this includes steps to reconstruct the palmar oblique ligament and/or suspend the thumb base using strips of tendon passed across the resection left after removal of the trapezium gap to maintain thumb base position. While the long-term advantage of these additional steps is controversial, many surgeons will undertake thumb base stabilisation after trapeziectomy, particularly in younger, higher-demand patients.
There are already excellent published surgical techniques on the Orthoracle site for simple trapeziectomy ( Trapeziectomy ), trapeziectomy with capsular flap interposition ( Trapeziectomy with capsuloperiosteal flap interposition arthroplasty ) and trapeziectomy with abductor pollicis longus suspensionplasty ( Trapeziectomy with APL suspensionplasty ); in this series, I aim to add detail and technical tips to enhance the already-published techniques to allow for easy, reproducible execution of this useful procedure.

INDICATIONS
Trapeziectomy is a good option for patients with symptomatic thumb-base arthritis (TMC joint, with or without associated STT arthritis) that has not responded to non-surgical measures; it will help patients with osteoarthritis, inflammatory arthritis, and older patients with post-traumatic arthritis.
SYMPTOMS & EXAMINATION
Patients almost always complain of pain; pain from the TMC joint is centred on the joint, and along the metacarpal, particularly in the region of the thenar muscles, and is worse with thumb pinch grips, such as using a key or holding a plate. Pain from the STT joint may be similar, but is usually worse with wrist motion and radiates into the forearm. Pain from the MCP joint is usually more distal to pain from the TMC joint, but is provoked by similar thumb pinch activities.
Pain from differential or co-existing pathologies may be reported; pain from carpal tunnel syndrome commonly affects the radial-sided fingers, but can also affect the forearm. Pain from de Quervain syndrome is usually along the radial border of the forearm and into the thumb.
Examination should look for the characteristic squaring of the thumb base seen with TMC arthritis (due to metacarpal subluxation associated with attenuation of the palmar oblique intrinsic ligament, and the pull of the adductor pollicis longus), and in more advanced cases potentially fixed adduction of the thumb metacarpal with compensatory MCP joint hyperextension; you should try to see if the metacarpal adduction can be corrected, if it is not too sore, and determine the extent and end point to and MCP joint hyperextension.
Spend time trying to establish which joints are maximally tender through careful, localised palpation, and which clinical provocation manoeuvres reproduce the patient’s normal symptoms. Provocation of the TMC joint can be confirmed by load-and-grind tests (to reduce the subluxed join, with or without axial compression, to reproduce pain); be careful not to involve the MCP joint while doing this if there is doubt. Involvement of the STT joint is indicated by pain on wrist motion, particularly the dart-throwing arc. The MCP joint can be screened by fixing the thumb metacarpal (being careful to avoid pressure on the TMC joint) and loading the MCP joint. In practice, there is rarely much clinical doubt.
There may be wasting of the thenar eminence muscles (due to disuse, but that may also suggest additional carpal tunnel compromise of the median nerve, which should be looked for) and also changes of small joint arthritis in other digit joints.
In rare cases, patients may be constitutionally lax, so particularly in patients presenting at a young age with early or established arthitis, screen the other joints to see if there is generalised laxity which may influence treatments (see below).
Be careful to assess patients’ fitness for general or regional anaesthesia, including whether or not they are taking anti-platelet of anti-coagulant medication.
IMAGING
For most patients, PA and lateral radiographs to confirm the clinical diagnosis of TMC arthritis and rule in or out STT arthritis is all that will be required to plan treatment.
Ultrasound may help with diagnosis, both to rule in or out de Quervain syndrome, to look for active synovitis and tenosynovitis, and to guide injections to provide diagnostic confirmation of the source of symptoms.
CT may help, particularly to assess bone stock and osteophyte distribution if arthroplasty is being contemplated.
Rarely, MRI may help if there is significant diagnostic doubt or concerns raised following plain film imaging.
NON-OPERATIVE MANAGEMENT
Most but not all patients will have tried simple analgesics before referral; it is worth confirming that these have been tried and are not acceptable when you first meet your patient. Some will also have tried dietary supplements, such as glucosamine and chondroitin sulphate or turmeric, or omega fish oils; some patients do find these helpful.
Splints may provide stability to the TMC joint, although many inhibit activities as they can be bulky, or prevent easy hand hygiene; none the less, a trial of resting splintage and functional splints (soft splints, commercially-available off-the-shelf splints such as Push Ortho CMC thumb brace, or custom splints from a hand therapist) may improve pain and function.
Hand therapists can also instruct and supervise patients with intrinsic strengthening exercises to improve dynamic control of the TMC joint, which again some find helpful. They can also advise patients about potentially useful activity modifications, and appliances that may make it easier for them to perform day-to-day tasks, such as grips for lids.
In terms of non-surgical interventions, injections of corticosteroid or hyaluronic acid preparations into the affected joint can produce periods of pain control; for some, this will provide adequate symptom relief until their functional demands naturally lessen, of the arthritic pain “burns out”.
ALTERNATIVE OPERATIVE TREATMENT
Procedures to preserve the trapezium in part or completely include:
For patients with very early arthritis, TMC stabilisation (using tendon palmar oblique ligament reconstruction, or artificial materials) or thermal capsular shrinkage may have a role, although this is limited other than following trauma to the palmar oblique ligament.
TMC and/or STT joint denervation. This can range from capsular exposure to selective nerve division to reduce pain information transmission from the TMC and STT joints. As the trapezium is retained, thumb length is maintained and, as long as pain on gripping is reduced, grip strength is maintained or improved; however, the results can be hard to predict, and may decay with time.
Partial trapezial excision with interposition. This removes less bone and so intuitively preserves length better. The interposition may be native tendon, or a range of artificial materials; these operations may help patients with isolated TMC arthritis, and allow foe subsequent excision of the remained of the trapezium, but the reoperation rate is higher than with a primary trapeziectomy.
TMC joint replacement (arthroplasty). Enthusiasm has waxed and waned for TMC joint replacement over the years, with problems arising largely through loosening of the trapezial component (or fracturing of the trapezium during or after insertion), and the potential from component dislocation of wear requiring further surgery, but the procedure can maintain thumb length, pinch grip strength, and can allow for a more rapid initial recovery. As with all surgical procedures, if well executed and for the right patient, this can be a very good alternative (with appropriate pre-operative counselling).
CONTRAINDICATIONS
The presence of local infection or of skin conditions that may increase the risk of a surgical site infection represent absolute and relative contraindications to surgery respectively; a past history of infection would make simple trapeziectomy more sensible as there will be a lover risk of recurrent deep infection if retained suture and potentially devitalised tendon is avoided.
Similarly, care should be taken when considering surgery for patients with active or a history of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) for fear of exacerbating the CRPS.
Patients with significant thumb MCP joint hyperextension are unlikely to regain grip strength unless the MCP joint is addressed; if the degree of hyper-extension exceeds 30 degrees, you should consider temporary K-wiring of the MCP joint, or a soft tissue (palmar plate reefing) or bony (sesamoid or total MCP joint arthrodesis) procedure simultaneously.
Patients with constitutional joint laxity will tend to stretch soft tissue stabilisation techniques for restoring thumb metacarpal base stability; you should consider using artificial graft materials, such as appropriately-sized Internal Brace or TightRope (both Arthrex)
Younger patients and those who require retention of powerful thumb grips are less likely to be pleased with the outcome of trapeziectomy surgery, with or without basal stabilisation. You should consider and discuss TMC fusion (assuming the STT remains healthy) for these patients, although the evidence that this will preserve strength is limited. Arthroplasty would be another option, but implant longevity would be a concern in these patients.
Overall, aside from infection and CRPS, there are very few contraindications to trapeziectomy, assuming patients have been appropriately advised about realistic surgical outcomes and risks.

Most patients prefer to have surgery using regional (axillary or more distal nerve blocks) or general anaesthetic; a tourniquet will usually be applied, but antibiotic prophylaxis is not routinely required.
Surgery can be performed using Wide Awake Local Anaesthetic No Tourniquet (WALANT- large volume infiltration of the surgical field using buffered local anaesthetic and adrenaline, potentially with median and superficial radial nerve blocks).
Most patients can be operated upon on a day-case basis, assuming appropriate local facilities and anaesthetic techniques are available.

The arm should be kept elevated when not in use, at or above the level of the heart (including supporting the hand on pillows overnight- retaining the Bradford sling can help as the surface tends to grip the pillow surface). I ask patients to actively mobilise the fingers as soon as any block allows, and to take oral analgesia as required, starting before or at least as soon as the local anaesthetic starts to wear off.
The plaster is changed for a removable thermoplastic splint at 10-114 days, allowing the wound to be checked and the suture removed (as above); if the Steristrips remain secure, these should be retained, but if not, breathable tape is applied across the wound to minimise stretching. Assuming the wound has healed, hand washing can be resumed, including use of a shower (but not soaking in a bath etc. until 3 weeks after surgery). The hand therapists should advise gentle and progressive thumb mobilisation, aiming to regain full opposition range by 6-8 weeks, but not undertake any resistance or strengthening work. Elevation can stop once the swelling subsides, as common sense allows. Scar massage is also commenced at this stage.
The thermoplastic splint is progressively weaned from at between 8 and 10 weeks, retained for rest and comfort. Oedema management is instituted as required. Mobilization progresses to include passive exercises and gentle strengthening exercises at between 8 and 12 weeks, during which the patient is allowed to gently ease back into simple routine activities but should avoid firm or prolonged pinch grips. Unrestricted activity and strengthening is allowed after 14-16 weeks.
Injury to the superficial sensory nerve branches can result in painful neuromas; this is best avoided by careful identification, dissection and protection of nerve branches, including placement of the incision at the junction of the palmar and dorsal skin. Once formed, neuromas can be extremely debilitating and may require surgical exploration. While major nerve branch injury is fortunately rare with careful surgical technique, distal sensory alteration is common, but usually recedes and becomes non-intrusive. Similarly, scar tenderness is a common problem even in the absence of defined nerve injury and is best managed by early institution of scar massage.
Proximal thumb metacarpal subsidence is a problem following all procedures requiring excision of the trapezium; to maximise maturation of the suspensionplasty and so minimise recurrent thumb base instability, I recommend patients refrain from firm and prolonged pinch grips for 12-14 weeks, as outlined above, although to date there is no robust evidence that this will improve the long-term outcome. Fortunately, the published literature reveals that for most patients, thumb shortening is not of significant functional importance.

Abductor pollicis longus tendon arthroplasty for treatment of arthrosis in the first carpometacarpal joint. (Sigfusson R, Lundborg G (1991) Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg Hand Surg 25:73-77). This study describes the APL surgical technique, noting the ease of the technique and lack of bone tunnel formation; they reported the outcome in 21 thumbs / 19 patients at a mean follow-up of 25 months, with pain improvement noted in all bar one patient and grip and pinch strengths showing marked improvement.
Five- to 18-year follow-up for treatment of trapeziometacarpal osteoarthritis: a prospective comparison of excision, tendon interposition, and ligament reconstruction and tendon interposition. (Gangopadhyay S, McKenna, Burke F, Davis TR. (2012) J Hand Surg Am. 2012 Mar;37(3):411-7).
This study 174 randomised patients to trapeziectomy alone, palmaris interposition, or FCR ligament reconstruction plus interposition, assessed with a minimum 5 year follow up. No significant difference was noted between the groups in terms of pain, grip or key pinch strength, or complication rate; 78% were noted to have had a good outcome.
Surgery for thumb (trapeziometacarpal joint) osteoarthritis. (Wajon A, Ada L, Edmunds I. (2005) The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2005, Issue 4. Art. No.: CD004631.pub2.) This systematic review of quasi-randomised and randomized, controlled trials assessing surgical treatments for TMC arthritis, comparing trapeziectomy alone, trapeziectomy with interposition arthroplasty, trapeziectomy with ligament reconstruction, trapeziectomy with ligament reconstruction and interposition, and replacement arthroplasty. They concluded that no one treatment modality had conclusively better outcomes than the others, although trapeziectomy alone had the lowest rate of reported complications.
Overall, while there is no compelling evidence that ligament reconstruction affords a long-term functional advantage to all patients undergoing trapeziectomy, surgeons remain uncomfortable undertaking simple trapeziectomy for younger, higher-demand patients due to the potential for thumb shortening and grip weakness, reflected in the reported less-than-good outcomes seen in 1:4-1:5 patients. Until arthroplasty has become more established in the UK, patients who have higher demands or have thumb metacarpal adduction will continue to be offered thumb-base stabilisation in addition to trapeziectomy, and using a simple technique, like APL suspensionplasty, provides good results for most patients without the need for expensive implants or equipment.
Reference
- orthoracle.com



























































