
Learn the Partial scapulectomy for chondrosarcoma surgical technique with step by step instructions on OrthOracle. Our e-learning platform contains high resolution images and a certified CME of the Partial scapulectomy for chondrosarcoma surgical procedure.
Osteochondromas represent approximately 1/3 of all benign bone tumours. They are an exostosis of bone that is covered by cartilage on its external surface. They typically present in the second or third decades of life and most frequently effect the appendicular skeleton, with the lower-limbs more commonly effected. They may be solitary or multiple hereditary osteochondromas. The risk of sarcomatous change is rare, seen in approximately 1% of solitary osteochondromas, with rates of 2-5% seen in hereditary multiple osteochrondromatosis (as in this case). Although classically osteochondromas are encountered in the metaphyseal region of appendicular long bones, axial tumours of the pelvis, spine, ribs, and scapula.
Surgery for benign osteochondromas should be avoided and only performed if they cause pain, decreased range of motion, pressure on neurovascular structures, tendon irritation or significant bursal formation. Clearly any clinical, pathological or radiological evidence of malignant transformation is also an indication for wide ‘en-bloc‘ resection of a possible chondrosarcoma.
In this case a young female patient suffered pain and limitation of movement as the osteochondroma continued to enlarge after skeletal maturity, a concerning feature of malignant transformation. An MRI pre-operatively had not excluded the possibility of malignant transformation and the biopsy was typically reassuring but subject to the sampling error renowned when biopsying possible chondrosarcomas. Unfortunately chondrosarcomas are not homogenous, and consequently high grade chondrosarcomas when carefully scrutinised after resection will have benign, low-grade and high-grade areas all within the same tumour, thus biopsy is considered unreliable. This has been reported by multiple research teams (Laitinen MK, Stevenson JD, Parry MC, Sumathi V, Grimer RJ, Jeys LM. The role of grade in local recurrence and the disease-specific survival in chondrosarcomas. Bone Joint J. 2018 May 1;100-B(5):662-666. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.100B5.BJJ-2017-1243.R1. PMID: 29701096). The sarcoma MDT took the view that given the clinical and radiological features were concerning for sarcomatous transformation in a pre-existing osteochondroma, that en-bloc excision was indicated.
Malawer classified shoulder girdle resections for patients undergoing limb sparing procedures for bone and soft tissue tumours: Type I, proximal humeral resection; type II, partial scapular resection; type III, total scapulectomy; type IV, total scapulectomy and extra-articular glenohumeral resection; type V, proximal humeral and glenoid resection; and type VI, proximal humeral and total scapular resection. Here we present a type II partial scapulectomy for peripheral chondrosarcoma without reconstruction.
OrthOracle reader will find the following related operative techniques also of interest:
Forequarter amputation for chondrosarcoma
Computer navigated P1 hemipelvectomy for chondrosarcoma and GRAFTJACKET (Wright Medical) reconstruction
Hindquarter amputation with pedicled fillet flap for clear cell chondrosarcoma of the proximal femur
Proximal femoral endoprosthetic replacement (Stanmore METS, Stryker) for chondrosarcoma

INDICATIONS
Indications for surgical removal include pain secondary to the tumour itself, or due to symptomatic compression of local anatomy such as nerve, blood vessels or tendons. Patients with hereditary multiple osteochodromatosis (HMO) (also known as hereditary multiple exostoses and diaphyseal aclasia) have growths of multiple osteochondromas, benign cartilage-capped bone tumours that grow outward from the metaphyses of long bones. HMO can be associated with a reduction in skeletal growth, bony deformity, restricted joint motion, shortened stature, premature osteoarthritis, and compression of peripheral nerves. Nearly all individuals are diagnosed by age 12 years, aided by a strong family history. Often as children have growth spurts, so too do their osteochondromas, which then become more prominent and symptomatic. These patients may also require surgery to correct deformities of the upper and lower-limb (e.g. ulna shortening osteotomies) and guided-growth for limb-length discrepancy.
Both solitary and multiple osteochondromas grow with children until they reach skeletal maturity. Any increase in size after skeletal maturity is concerning for malignant transformation which is rare, possibly 1% in solitary osteochondromas and 2-5% in hereditary multiple osteochondromatosis. Malignant transformation is more common in pelvic and scapula (axial) sites, less common around the knee and exceptional in the extremities.
There are no clear guidelines for management of these patients throughout their lives but commonly they are managed by local paediatric surgeons until lesions require more specialist care at tertiary orthopaedic oncology centres (in my experience). There are also no guidelines for surveillance but my personal preference is to do a baseline whole-body MRI at skeletal maturity so that we have imaging to compare with any future MRI scans querying malignant transformation in the future.
SYMPTOMS & EXAMINATION
They normally present as a painless mass though can cause symptoms secondary to formation of an overlying bursa due to friction, or to activity-related discomfort. Very occasionally, the lesion may cause neuropathic symptoms due to compression of a nearby nerve or may fracture producing sudden pain. They may well also be asymptomatic. In this case the gradual growth of the tumour had caused deformity of the underlying rib-cage, was painfully limiting scapulothoracic movement and causing difficulty with clothing.
If present symptoms will include pain, decreased range of motion, pressure on neurovascular structures, tendon irritation or significant bursal formation. A sudden change in symptoms should prompt re-evaluation and may indicate malignant transformation to a chondrosarcoma.
Such secondary peripheral chondrosarcomas arise in the cartilage cap of a longstanding osteochondroma. Those located in the pelvis and scapula seem to be the most susceptible to malignant change, perhaps because these sites permit undetected growth. Malignant transformation occurs in 1% of solitary osteochondromas and unto 5% of patients with hereditary multiple osteochondromatosis. This change is often seen in the fourth decade. HMO is an autosomal dominant disorder; in almost 96% of MO patients germline mutations in the tumour suppressor genes EXT1 or EXT2 are present, meaning that the remainder are de-novo variants.
IMAGING
Xray findings are very characteristic and allow quantification and documentation of size and location.
The lesion appears as a bony protuberance with well-defined limits, thin outer cortex and an inner cancellous structure. The pathgnomic feature is that the host bone flares from the cortex into the osteochondroma. Some are pedunculated with a cauliflower-like summit, whilst others have a broad, sessile base. Pedunculated osteochondromas typically point away from the joint, towards the diaphysis.
MRI demonstrates the classic cartilaginous cap which ranges from a few millimetres to a centimetre or more. The cap is typically thicker in children diminishing with age. MRI imaging is used to exclude malignant transformation or assist in diagnosis if plain radiographs are equivocal. A cartilage cap thicker than 2cm when measured with MRI is thought to be at a greater risk of undergoing malignant transformation according to Bernard et al. (Bernard SA, Murphey MD, Flemming DJ, Kransdorf MJ. Improved differentiation of benign osteochondromas from secondary chondrosarcomas with standardized measurement of cartilage cap at CT and MR imaging. Radiology. 2010 Jun;255(3):857-65. doi: 10.1148/radiol.10082120. Epub 2010 Apr 14. PMID: 20392983). and therefore, if morbidity is acceptable, would be considered for surgical excision.
CONTRAINDICATIONS
In asymptomatic lesions, treatment is not indicated. Excision may be warranted in large lesions where local pressure effects may occur or in adults where the risk of malignant transformation warrants removal.

Anaesthesia:
General anaesthetic with single dose pre-operative IV antibiotic prophylaxis (we use Flucloxacillin and Gentamicin).
Tranexamic acid single dose pre-operatively.
Positioning:
Lateral position with pressure area cushioning for contralateral shoulder, elbow, knee. Carter Bain arm support for the operative limb.
Theatre:
Ultra-clean Howarth ventilated theatre and canopy.
Equipment:
Cautery, suction, general orthopaedic set, oscillating saw/osteotomes, drains, sutures.
Thromboprophylaxis:
TED stockings for six weeks (unless contraindications), chemical prophylaxis until mobile.

HDU overnight for observation.
VAC dressing to be removed 7 days and wound reviewed (this is the longest our tissue viability team will allow vacuum dressings to remain without being changed)
Removal of drains when less than 50mls over 24 hours.
Analgesia and dietary supplements.
Contact patient with results of histology when available.
Keep sling in place for 2 weeks for pain relief then begin passive circumduction exercises and progress to active movements by 4-6 weeks.

The most common primary malignant bone tumours involving the scapula are chondrosarcomas and Ewing’s sarcoma according to Vahanan et al. (Mayil Vahanan, N., Mohanlal, P., Bose, J.C. et al. The functional and oncological results after scapulectomy for scapular tumours: 2–16-year results. International Orthopaedics (SICO 31, 831–836 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00264-006-0261-1). Other indications may include soft-tissue sarcomas and metastatic bone disease.
Malawer classified shoulder girdle resections into six groups depending upon whether all or part of the scapula and humerus are resected and whether the procedure involves a glenonhumeral arthrotomy or an extra-articular resection (Malawer MM, Meller I, Dunham WK. A new surgical classification system for shoulder-girdle resections. Analysis of 38 patients. Clin Orthop 1991;(267):33–44). A partial scapulectomy where the neck of the scapula and the glenoid were retained, as in this case, is classified as type II resection.
Gibbons et al. reported function after scapulectomy for neoplasms of bone and soft tissues. In their series of 14 cases they noted that resection of 80% of the scapula had only a modest effect on function. They also noted that subtotal scapulectomy gave an excellent functional result if all or part of the glenohumeral joint could be preserved (Gibbons CL, Bell RS, Wunder JS, Griffin AM, O’Sullivan B, Catton CN, Davis AM. Function after subtotal scapulectomy for neoplasm of bone and soft tissue. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1998 Jan;80(1):38-42. doi: 10.1302/0301-620x.80b1.8183. PMID: 9460950), which was confirmed by Vahanan et al., who reported superior functional results if the glenoid was preserved and stated that useful shoulder function may be expected if the muscles are reconstructed around the shoulder, namely the deltoid and trapezius.
As the scapula and pelvis are considered to both represent axial, flat bone locations for primary bone sarcomas, the article by Tsuda et al. is relevant. The authors identified that local recurrence of peripheral chondrosarcomas is predicated by the surgical resection margin width. Local recurrence of chondrosarcoma is associated with inoperable tumours and death. A margin of 1 mm or more was sufficient to minimise the risk of local recurrence and is the only outcome that surgeons can influence for their patients (Tsuda et al. Is the width of a surgical margin associated with the outcome of disease in patients with peripheral chondrosarcoma of the pelvis. Clinic Orthop Relat Res 2019 Nov; 477(11): 2432–2440.doi: 10.1097/CORR.0000000000000926).
Reference
- orthoracle.com























































