
Learn the Triple fusion: For calcaneal fracture malunion surgical technique with step by step instructions on OrthOracle. Our e-learning platform contains high resolution images and a certified CME of the Triple fusion: For calcaneal fracture malunion surgical procedure.
The triple Fusion is an effective procedure to treat both severe arthritic symptoms and deformity of the hindfoot. The joints addressed in this operation are the subtalar, the talonavicular and the calcaneocuboid joint. Key to the procedure is joint preparation and correction of the deformity, aiming to achieve a solidly united foot in the correct alignment in order to restore the mechanical axis and provide a foot the fits adequately it into a shoe.
Hind foot pain and arthritis following calcaneal fractures can be challenging to treat. There are though a limited number of well recognised potential causes for pain, that should be carefully enquired about in every patient suffering after calcaneal fracture, whether they have been treated primarily by operative reduction and fixation, or not. Lateral hindfoot pain, in the region of the fibular tip, can occur secondary to subtalar fibrosis, subtalar arthritis or lateral wall impingement, or all of these. Pain from the plantar aspect of the heel can occur due to malunion of the plantar surface of the calcaneus or disruption of the heel fat pad at the time of injury. A loss of support for the talus, secondary to flattening of Bohlers angle, can lead to a dorsiflexed talus and anterior ankle impingement.
When surgically salvaging a malunited calcaneal fracture there can be a number of novel challenges, including a “blown-out”, widened lateral calcaneal wall that can make access to the subtalar joint difficult and causes subfibular impingement. Bone loss and impaction of the posterior facet of the subtalar joint that may leave bone voids and also effect produce dorsi-flexion of the talar body, leading to anterior ankle impingement (that needs to be addressed by resupporting the talus with a structural bone graft inserted intothe posterior aspect of the subtalar joint). Partial unions associated with the fracture, such as of the anterior process, may need to be addressed at the same time as the arthrodesis procedure.
Careful consideration should be given to accessing the relevant joints, malunions, and nonunions prior to surgery, in order to plan the optimal approach to address each of these issues. Access may be different to the standard sinus tarsi approach employed for the primarily degenerate subtalar joint.
The lateral approach to the calcaneum is well established in treatment of calcaneal fractures and incorporates the angiosome of the peroneal artery. The same extensile approach can be utilised for a subtalar arthrodesis where the dorsal flap is elevated along with the peroneal tendons up to the tip of the fibula to expose the lateral wall of the calcaneum and the subtalar joint. The subtalar joint is often obscured in cases where the lateral wall has been particularly blown-out and once the lateral wall is excised an excellent exposure to the subtalar joint can be achieved.
Functionally patients with their triple arthrodesis can perform very well during standard activities of daily living although they may encounter some stiffness and difficulty on uneven ground. However, it should be put into context that function is often very restricted prior to surgery in any case. Such limitations as may occur post-operatively can be minimised with an appropriate orthotic and shoewear combination.
OrthOracle readers will also find the following associated techniques of interest:
Calcaneal fracture: fixation with extended lateral approach and ZimmerBiomet ALPS plate
Calcaneal fracture: Percutaneous fixation of Tongue-type fracture.
Calcaneal fracture fixation: Extended lateral approach and locking plate fixation
Calcaneal fracture fixation : Internal fixation of sustentaculum tali fracture (Acutrak screws)
Triple Fusion
Subtalar fusion and Talonavicular arthrodesis (open technique) using Stryker anchorage 2 plating system
Arthroscopic subtalar fusion

INDICATIONS
In my practice the following are the commoner indications for triple fusion:
-Symptomatic degenerative change from any cause effecting at least 2 of the triple joints.
-Symptomatic tarsal coalition in the adult of greater than 50% of the joint involved or with associated degenerative change.
-Post traumatic osteoarthritis following calcaneal fracture.
-Stage 3 (Anderson & Strom) tibialis posterior tendinosis or failed reconstructive joint preserving surgery for stage 2 tibialis posterior tendinosis or stage 2 tendinosis in the elderly patient requiring surgery.
-Severe flexible uncontrolled, but non-arthritic, deformity in a neuromuscular patient.
SYMPTOMS & EXAMINATION
Pain is usually the overriding presenting complaint this is usually felt laterally in the subfibular area of the hindfoot. It is felt dorsally over the talo-navicular joint and occasionally over the anterior ankle if there has been significant collapse of the posterior facet, creating a dorsi-flexion of the talus and impingement of the talar neck on the anterior tibia.
With significant deformity, pain can result from pressure and overload either from the ground or from footwear. With severe deformity pain can be felt more proximally due to an alteration in the loading pattern and mechanics of the lower limb. Pain tends to be worse on weight bearing and is largely mechanical, but with significant inflammation, night and rest pain can occur. Pain is often provoked by walking on uneven ground.
The triple joint contributes to composite foot and ankle dorsi and plantar-flexion, so if the subtalar, talonavicular or calcaneo cuboid joints are stiff this will reduce the total range of movement. When examining individual joints to assess their mobility and the presence or absence of pain, it is also important to assess the alignment of the ankle the hindfoot, midfoot and forefoot.
If deformity is present, assessment of where this deformity occurs should be made and also whether it is fixed or flexible. In the case of post traumatic arthritis following calcaneal fracture there is often a significant degree of stiffness in the subtalar joint. The position of the heel in malunited calcaneal fractures can often be significantly varus and this will need to be taken into account during the correction. Areas of prominence over the Achilles posteriorly and the heel pad plantarly should be noted. There is often a loss of the normal contour of the hindfoot in the sub lateral-malleolar area. With normal anatomy there is a “step off” and the tip of the fibula can be palpated. However with a blown out lateral calcaneal wall, the tip of the fibula can be difficult to appreciate. The Choparts joints should also be carefully examined for associated stiffness or pain.
IMAGING
CT and MRI scans or very helpful in assessing chondropathy, degenerative change, union of calcaneal fractures and the location of deformity and the fracture pattern.
I find that weight bearing CT scans can be particularly useful in assessing both union and alignment of the ankle and the hind foot.
ALTERNATIVE OPERATIVE TREATMENT
See also the links to these relevant procedures in the overview section.
Isolated fusion: each of the joints of the hindfoot complex may be fused in isolation, it should be remembered of course they work as a functional unit and fusing one will reduce the range of movement through the remaining joints, however isolated fusions will preserve more movement than a triple fusion.
Bone block distraction Triple Fusion: In the presence of significant deformity by direct intra articular correction through the prepared joints may not be enough, in which case a cortical bone graft could be utilised to pack into the posterior subtalar joint. Depending on how the graft is positioned, it can be used to address both the talar inclination as well as hindfoot varus or valgus. Alternatively simultaneously perfomed osteotomies, such as a medialising or plantarising calcaneal osteotomy are sometimes required.
Subtalar Arthroscopy: for milder or isolated subtalar arthritis.
Reconstructive osteotomy of the calcaneus, combined with subtalar arthrodesis: As described in the seminal paper by MM Romasch (Clin Orthop Relat Res 1993 May:290; 157-67
NON-OPERATIVE MANAGEMENT:
Non-operative management includes footwear modification, such as shoes that are deeper or wider to accommodate the foot.
Lace up shoes or boots may provide some stability to the hindfoot, and functional foot orthoses maybe helpful, particularly in those with deformity.
Image guided steroid and local anaesthetic injections can provide both therapeutic benefit, and be useful as a diagnostic tool.
CONTRAINDICATIONS
Active infection, ulceration, open wounds, arterial insufficiency, and smoking are contra-indications to surgery. Care should also be taken in those taking certain medications such as steroids or immuno-modulating medications.

Triple fusion can be performed with a GA or regional anaesthesia
Popliteal blocks for post-operative pain relief
Laminar flow theatre.
Peri-operative antibiotics.
6 weeks of post operative LMW Heparin
Thigh tourniquet.
Flowtron on contra-lateral calf
Ankle positioned into neutral using sandbags & side supports
A large sterile bolster behind the ankle will improve access.

2 weeks in back-slab cast.
DVT prophylaxis for 6 weeks.
Dressing changes at 2 weeks
Complete cast between weeks0- 4 non-weight bearing, 4-8 weeks partial weight bearing, 8-12 weeks fully weight bearing
Check X-ray at 12 week consider CT if equivocal, complex cases with bone graft, We routinely use a weight-bearing CT scan to assess union.
Into long post-operative boot and gradual increase in weight-bearing at this stage as symptoms allow .
Interpretation of Xrays must be taken in conjunction with clinical symptoms.
A patient who has responded to increased weight bearing by getting increasing pain around the fusion site by the 12 week stage may require further imaging in the form of a CT scan. Dealing with this scenario it is important to be clear of the location of any pain so a thorough history and examination can prove invaluable. Heel pain can occur simply due to plantar fascitis as most patients walk with a shorter step between week 6 and 12 which will load the soft tissues of the heel proportionally more than normal.If pain is from the calf a DVT should be considered even at this stage. If clinically the fusion mass appears to be the source of pain then weight-bearing should be reduced for a further 4-6 weeks (using post-operative boot & crutches) 4-6 weekly assessments are then required until pain and imaging improves.

Clinical outcome after primary triple arthrodesis.
J Bone Joint Surg.2000.82-A.1;47-57.
R.F.Pell ,M.S.Myerson ,L.W.Schon.
111 patients followed up for an average of 5.7 years (range of 2 -10.8 years). Modern fixation technique with screws used. No Charcot , revision or infected cases were included.
Only 3 non-unions reported. A high correlation between alignment & outcome and a poor correlation between the progressive arthritic change in the same foot and outcome . The incidence of arthritis increased from 7% pre-operatively to 60% post-operatively (predominantly ankle).”
Triple arthrodesis using internal fixation in treatment of adult foot disorders.
Clinical Orthopaedics and related research.1993.294; 299-307
B.J.Sangeorzan,D.Smith,R.Veith,S.T.Hansen
44 feet fused using screw fixation in a varied group of neuro-muscular , post-traumatic and primary arthritic patients.
2 non-unions . 40 feet with a good or fair result and 4 classified as failure( the non-unions and two varus deformities).
A physical activity score was also used (AIMS) indicating little restriction in the main re the activities of daily living.
Triple Arthrosedis:twenty five and fourty-four year average follow-up of the same patients.
J Bone Joint Surg.1999.81-A;1391-1402.
C I Saltzmann, MJ Fehrle ,RR Cooper ,EC Spencer ,IV Ponsetti.
67 feet of which approximately 70% had a neurological or neuromuscular condition . “Historical”means of internal fixation with initial review performed in 1974 and at 25 years post op.
Perhaps unsurprisingly non-union found in almost 20%.
Pain was present in 45% of feet at 25 years and 55% at 44 years
Progressive arthritic changes noted in 69 % of ankles 82% of , Naviculo-cuneiform and 68% of tarso-metatarsal articulations by 25 years.”
Isolated Subtalar Arthrodesis.
J Bone Joint Surg.2000.82-A;613-624
M.E.Easley, H.Trnka,L.C.Shon,M.S.Myerson”
148 patients followed up for mean of 51 months (range 24 -130)
86%primary union rate reported and 71 % union after revision subtalar fusion .
Subgroups identified within this study with an increased incidence of non-union were smokers (46% of the group) , previous failed fusions , subtalar fusions using structural graft and subtalar fusions beneath ankles that were already fused.
Comparative non-union rates in triple arthrodesis
J Foot Ankle Surg 2018 57(6) 1154-6
Klasse L, Shi E, Weintraub GM, Liu J.
157 triple arthrodeses Overall non-union rate was 29.9%. Talonavicular 20.4%, Subtalar 8.9%, Calcaneo-cuboid 17.2%.
They found the most reliable preparation for arthrodesis was joint resection or curettage in association with fish-scaling.
Subtalar versus triple arthrodesis after intra-articular calcaneal fractures
Stratergies limb trauma reconstr 2010 Aug:5(2): 97-103
Schepers T, Kieboo BCT, Bessems GHJM, Vogels LMM, Van Lieshout EMM, Patka P.
Between 2 and 30% of patients with displaced intra-articular fractures of the calcaneum will require a secondary arthrodesis. This study looked at the relative functional outcomes following triple arthrodesis or isolated sub-talar fusion. 17 Subtalar, 20 triple arthrodeses with a median follow up of 116 months. Whilst smoking was associated with a significant increased non-union in both groups, there was no significant difference between the outcomes of triple fusion and isolated subtalar joint.
Subtalar fusion after displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures: does initial operative treatment matter?JBJS Am. 2009 Mar 1;91(3): 541-6Radnay CS, ClareMP, Sanders RW.
The authors hypothesized that patients who had undergone prior surgical management to reduce and the calcaneal fracture would have a better outcome from hindfoot arthrodesis than non-reduced, conservatively operated fractures.They treated 69 consecutive patients with 75 displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures. 34 patients treated operatively, 35 non-operatively. They reported similar union rates, but significantly better functional outcomes and fewer wound complications in those treated with open reduction and internal fixation. Given the high incidence of post-traumatic arthritis, the authors support primary reduction and fixation for displaced intra-articular fractures on the basis that they will improve long term functional outcomes in those requiring arthrodesis.
Subtalar versus triple arthrodesis after intra-articular calcaneal fractures
Stratergies limb trauma reconstr 2010 Aug:5(2): 97-103
Schepers T, Kieboo BCT, Bessems GHJM, Vogels LMM, Van Lieshout EMM, Patka P.
Between 2 and 30% of patients with displaced intra-articular fractures of the calcaneum will require a secondary arthrodesis. This study looked at the relative functional outcomes following triple arthrodesis or isolated sub-talar fusion. 17 Subtalar, 20 triple arthrodeses with a median follow up of 116 months. Whilst smoking was associated with a significant increased non-union in both groups, there was no significant difference between the outcomes of triple fusion and isolated subtalar joint.
Reference
- orthoracle.com










































































